The Matrix.org Foundation posted yesterday that “public Matrix servers will also have to uphold age verification laws, as misguided as they might be.” This is true for them. They’re based in the UK and subject to the Online Safety Act. But it is not true as a general statement, and it’s not true for us.
Unredacted is a 501(c)(3) non-profit incorporated in Delaware that builds Internet infrastructure and services to help people access the open Internet and protect their right to privacy. We run Tor relays and bridges, operate FreeSocks to provide free VPNs to people in censored countries, run proxies for Signal and Telegram, and host free and open federated chat services, including our Matrix homeserver and XMPP.is. Our infrastructure is in the United States. We are subject to US law. The UK Online Safety Act does not apply to us, and no US law requires us to comply with it.
The SPEECH Act (28 U.S.C. §§ 4101-4105) specifically prohibits US courts from enforcing foreign content-based judgments unless the foreign law provides at least as much free speech protection as the First Amendment. The Online Safety Act doesn’t come close. It mandates removal of constitutionally protected speech, imposes proactive content monitoring, and criminalizes content that is legal here. The SPEECH Act also incorporates Section 230, which shields platforms from liability for user-generated content. Every state has adopted laws that exclude foreign regulatory fines from enforcement. The US-UK Mutual Legal Assistance Treaty covers criminal matters only and explicitly excludes regulatory enforcement. There is no treaty or agreement that requires a US entity to comply with UK administrative regulations.
The US government has taken this position too. FTC Chairman Ferguson warned tech companies in August 2025 that censoring Americans at the request of a foreign power could violate US law, naming the Online Safety Act specifically. 4chan and Kiwi Farms filed a federal lawsuit challenging Ofcom’s enforcement on First Amendment and SPEECH Act grounds.
What about US age verification laws? Also not applicable.
There is no federal age verification law for general Internet services. COPPA, the only relevant federal law, applies to commercial websites and online services. The FTC explicitly states it does not apply to nonprofit entities exempt from Section 5 of the FTC Act. We are a 501(c)(3). COPPA does not apply to us.
At the state level, 25 states have passed age verification laws, but they target commercial pornography sites (where a third or more of the content is pornographic) and large commercial social media platforms (often with revenue thresholds of $100 million+). We are a non-profit running federated chat servers. None of these laws were written for us and none of them apply.
The Supreme Court upheld age verification for adult content sites in Free Speech Coalition v. Paxton last June, but that ruling was narrow and specific to commercial pornographic websites. Courts have continued to block most social media age verification laws on First Amendment grounds.
We prohibit illegal content and material that causes real harm across all of our services, Matrix and XMPP.is alike: no CSAM of any kind, no threats of violence, no content that harms humans or animals. Over the years we’ve put real work into responding to abuse reports and clamping down on misuse of our platforms. We do this because those are our values, not because a foreign regulator demands it and not because we’re legally required to age-gate our chat servers.
We will not be implementing age verification. We will not be collecting government IDs from our users. These things are antithetical to why Unredacted exists. Our entire purpose is to help people communicate freely and privately, whether that’s someone in a censored country connecting to Signal through our proxies or someone joining a Matrix room on our homeserver. Building a surveillance apparatus on top of that would undermine everything we do.
Matrix.org is right about one thing: in Matrix you have the opportunity to run your own servers as you wish. We encourage everyone to take them up on that. If you’re coming from Discord, don’t register on matrix.org. It’s UK-based and subject to the Online Safety Act. Register on a server that isn’t.





























